Other

Cambie Gardens Energy Limited Partnership Complaint filed by S.U.C.C.E.S.S. Affordable Housing Society and the City of Vancouver

Completed: 2024

S.U.C.C.E.S.S. Affordable Housing Society and the City of Vancouver have filed a complaint with the BCUC regarding the thermal energy system owned by Cambie Gardens Energy Limited Partnership to serve SUCCESS at 603 West 59th Ave., Vancouver, BC and other customers at 7433 Cambie Street, Vancouver, BC. SUCCESS and the City have been unable to reach agreement with Cambie on the rates and terms for the delivery of space heating and hot water.

Hearing and Other Documents

Title Document Description
EXHIBIT LIST Updated: May 14, 2024 @ 2:30 pm
G-249-24 Final Order September 24, 2024

Arguments/Submissions

Title Document Description
SUCCESS-COV Final Argument-Public Final Argument March 19, 2024
Cambie Gardens Final Argument Final Argument March 19, 2024
SUCCESS-COV Argument on Additional Evidence - Confidential Confidential Argument on Additional Evidence May 28, 2024
Cambie Gardens Argument on Additional Evidence Argument on Additional Evidence May 28, 2024
SUCCESS-COV Reply Argument - Confidential Confidential Reply Argument June 11, 2024
Cambie Gardens Reply Argument - Confidential Confidential Reply Argument June 11, 2024

Exhibits

A Exhibits - BCUC Documents

Date Title Document Description
August 03, 2023 A-2 Letter dated August 3, 2023 – BCUC request to Cambie Gardens to file a response
August 10, 2023 A-3 Letter dated August 10, 2023 – BCUC response to Cambie Gardens request for an extension
August 24, 2023 A-1 Letter dated July 19, 2023 – BCUC Panel Appointment for the review of the complaint filed against Cambie Gardens Energy Limited Partnership by S.U.C.C.E.S.S Affordable Housing Society and the City of Vancouver
August 28, 2023 A-4 Letter dated August 28, 2023 – BCUC request to SUCCESS and CoV to provide reply submissions
September 29, 2023 A-5 Letter dated September 29, 2023 – BCUC amending the panel for the review of the complaint filed by S.U.C.C.E.S.S. Affordable Housing Society and the City of Vancouver
October 11, 2023 A-6 Letter dated October 11, 2023 – BCUC amending the panel for review of the application
October 12, 2023 A-7 Letter dated October 12, 2023 – BCUC order G-271-23 establishing a timetable with Reasons for Decision
November 02, 2023 A-8 Letter dated November 2, 2023 – BCUC request for submissions regarding confidentiality
November 02, 2023 A-9 Letter dated November 2, 2023 – BCUC request to Cambie Gardens for supplemental information
November 10, 2023 A-10 Letter dated November 10, 2023 – BCUC order G-306-23 with an amended regulatory timetable and a determination on confidentiality with Reasons for Decision
November 21, 2023 A-11 PUBLIC – Letter dated November 21, 2023 – BCUC Information Request No.1 to Cambie Gardens
November 21, 2023 A-12 CONFIDENTIAL – Letter dated November 21, 2023 – BCUC Confidential Information Request No.1 to Cambie Gardens
November 21, 2023 A-13 Letter dated November 21, 2023 – BCUC Information Request No. 1 to SUCCESS and CoV
November 29, 2023 A-14 Letter dated November 29, 2023 – BCUC response to SUCCESS and CoV extension request to file Information Request No. 1
December 13, 2023 A-15 Letter dated December 13, 2023 - BCUC response to extension requests by SUCCESS and CoV and CGE
January 11, 2024 A-16 Letter dated January 11, 2024 – BCUC order G-5-24 establishing a further regulatory timetable
January 24, 2024 A-17 CONFIDENTIAL – Letter dated January 24, 2024 – BCUC Confidential Information Request No. 2 to SUCCESS and CoV
January 24, 2024 A-18 CONFIDENTIAL – Letter dated January 24, 2024 – BCUC Confidential Information Request No. 2 to Cambie Gardens
February 15, 2024 A-19 Letter dated February 15, 2024 – BCUC will amend the regulatory timetable in due course
February 23, 2024 A-20 Letter dated February 23, 2024 – BCUC Order G-47-24 amending the regulatory timetable
April 02, 2024 A-21 CONFIDENTIAL – Letter dated April 2, 2024 – BCUC request to Cambie Gardens for additional information
April 08, 2024 A-22 Letter dated April 8, 2024 – BCUC pausing the regulatory timetable with further process to be determined
April 12, 2024 A-23 Letter dated April 12, 2024 – BCUC Order G-109-24 with confidential letter requesting more information
April 19, 2024 A-24 Letter dated April 19, 2024 – BCUC response to Cambie Gardens extension request
May 14, 2024 A-25 Letter dated May 14, 2024 – BCUC Order G-131-24 establishing a further regulatory timetable
January 24, 2024 A2-1 Letter dated January 24, 2024 – BCUC staff submitting FAES Application for Approval of the Rates Established in Amended Agreements for Thermal Energy Services for the TELUS Garden Development in Compliance with Order C-1-13

B Exhibits - Applicant Documents

Date Title Document Description
April 29, 2024 B2-16 CONFIDENTIAL - Letter dated April 29, 2024 – Cambie Gardens submitting confidential response to Exhibit A-23
April 19, 2024 B2-15 Letter dated April 19, 2024 – Cambie Gardens requesting extension for filing response to Exhibit A-23
April 05, 2024 B2-14 CONFIDENTIAL - Letter dated April 5, 2024 – Cambie Gardens submitting confidential additional information
February 07, 2024 B2-13 CONFIDENTIAL - Letter dated February 7, 2024 – Cambie Gardens submitting confidential responses to SUCCESS and CoV Information Request No. 2
February 07, 2024 B2-12 CONFIDENTIAL - Letter dated February 7, 2024 – Cambie Gardens submitting confidential responses to BCUC Information Request No. 2
January 25, 2024 B2-11-1 CONFIDENTIAL - Letter dated January 24, 2024 – Cambie Gardens submitting confidential Information Request No. 2 to SUCCESS and CoV
January 24, 2024 B2-11 PUBLIC - Letter dated January 24, 2024 – Cambie Gardens submitting public Information Request No. 2 to SUCCESS and CoV
December 14, 2023 B2-10 CONFIDENTIAL - Letter dated December 14, 2023 – Cambie Gardens submitting confidential responses to SUCCESS and CoV Confidential Information Request No. 1
December 14, 2023 B2-9 CONFIDENTIAL - Letter dated December 14, 2023 – Cambie Gardens submitting confidential responses to BCUC Confidential Information Request No. 1
December 14, 2023 B2-8-1 CONFIDENTIAL - Letter dated December 14, 2023 – Cambie Gardens submitting confidential responses to BCUC Information Request No. 1
December 14, 2023 B2-8 Letter dated December 14, 2023 – Cambie Gardens submitting public responses to BCUC Information Request No. 1
December 12, 2023 B2-7 Letter dated December 12, 2023 – Cambie Gardens submitting response to SUCCESS and CoV extension request to file Information Request No. 1 responses
November 28, 2023 B2-6 Letter dated November 28, 2023 – Cambie Gardens submitting Information Request No. 1 to SUCCESS and CoV
November 07, 2023 B2-5-1 CONFIDENTIAL - Letter dated November 7, 2023 – Cambie Gardens confidential response to BCUC request for supplemental information
November 07, 2023 B2-5 REDACTED - Letter dated November 7, 2023 – Cambie Gardens redacted response to BCUC request for supplemental information
October 26, 2023 B2-4-1 CONFIDENTIAL - Letter dated October 26, 2023 – Cambie Gardens confidential response to BCUC request for further information
October 26, 2023 B2-4 REDACTED - Letter dated October 26, 2023 – Cambie Gardens redacted response to BCUC request for further information
October 03, 2023 B2-3 Letter dated October 3, 2023 – Cambie Gardens submission regarding panel amendment
August 18, 2023 B2-2 Letter dated August 18, 2023 – Cambie Gardens submitting response to SUCCESS and CoV complaint
August 09, 2023 B2-1 CAMBIE GARDENS ENERGY LIMITED PARTNERSHIP (CGELP-CAMBIE GARDENS) – Extension request to file response to complaint dated August 9, 2023
April 05, 2024 B1-19 Letter dated April 5, 2024 – SUCCESS and CoV request opportunity to question CGE responses to BCUC Information Request No. 3
February 07, 2024 B1-18 CONFIDENTIAL - Letter dated February 7, 2024 – SUCCESS and CoV submitting responses to BCUC confidential Information Request No. 2
February 07, 2024 B1-17 CONFIDENTIAL - Letter dated February 7, 2024 – SUCCESS and CoV submitting responses to CGELP confidential Information Request No. 2
January 24, 2024 B1-16 CONFIDENTIAL - Letter dated January 24, 2024 – SUCCESS and CoV submitting confidential Information Request No. 2 to Cambie Gardens
December 14, 2023 B1-15 CONFIDENTIAL - Letter dated December 14, 2023 – SUCCESS and CoV submitting confidential responses to Cambie Gardens Information Request No. 1
December 14, 2023 B1-14 CONFIDENTIAL - Letter dated December 14, 2023 – SUCCESS and CoV submitting confidential responses to BCUC Information Request No. 1
December 08, 2023 B1-13 Letter dated December 8, 2023 – CoV submitting Confidentiality Declaration and Undertaking Form
December 12, 2023 B1-12 Letter dated December 12, 2023 – SUCCESS and CoV submitting extension request to file Information Request No. 1 responses
December 04, 2023 B1-11 Letter dated December 4, 2023 – CoV submitting Confidentiality Declaration and Undertaking Form
December 01, 2023 B1-10 CONFIDENTIAL - Letter dated December 1, 2023 - SUCCESS and CoV submitting confidential Information Request No. 1 to Cambie Gardens
December 01, 2023 B1-9 Letter dated November 27, 2023 – CoV submitting Confidentiality Declaration and Undertaking Form
November 28, 2023 B1-8 Letter dated November 28, 2023 – SUCCESS and CoV submitting extension request to file Information Request No. 1 to Cambie Gardens
November 27, 2023 B1-7 Letter dated November 27, 2023 – SUCCESS and CoV submitting Confidentiality Declaration and Undertaking Forms
November 17, 2023 B1-6 Letter dated November 17, 2023 – CoV submitting Confidentiality Declaration and Undertaking Form
November 17, 2023 B1-5 Letter dated November 17, 2023 – SUCCESS submitting Confidentiality Declaration and Undertaking Form
November 15, 2023 B1-4 Letter dated November 15, 2023 – SUCCESS and CoV submitting Confidentiality Declaration and Undertaking Forms
November 07, 2023 B1-3 Letter dated November 7, 2023 – SUCCESS and CoV response regarding Cambie Gardens request for information request confidentiality
September 13, 2023 B1-2 Letter dated September 13, 2023 – SUCCESS and CoV reply submission to BCUC as requested
June 30, 2023 B1-1 S.U.C.C.E.S.S. (SUCCESS) AFFORDABLE HOUSING SOCIETY AND THE CITY OF VANCOUVER (COV) - Complaint under Section 83 and TES Guidelines filed against Cambie Gardens Energy Limited Partnership (CGELP-Cambie Gardens) dated June 30, 2023

Our Review Process

Learn more about how we review applications, which are submitted to us by the entities we regulate. You'll see the types of reviews we conduct and how you can get involved in the process.

Learn more