Creative Energy

Creative Energy Vancouver Platforms Inc. Application for a Certificate of Public Convenience and Necessity for the Beatty-Expo Plants and Reorganization ~ Project No. 1598962

Completed: 2020

Hearing and Other Documents

This section can include a list of all exhibits issued in the proceeding and the BCUC's final decision.

Title Document Description
*_Exhibit List Updated: January 14, 2020 @ 4:05 pm
*_Decision and Order G-38-19 February 19, 2019
*_Decision and Final Order C-1-20 Decision and Final Order March 5, 2020
*_Creative Energy Response to Item 6 Order C-1-20 Creative Energy Response to Item 6 Order C-1-20
*_ Order C-1-20 - Creative Response 2020-03-19 Creative Energy Response to C-1-20
*_Panel Report Panel Report April 3, 2020

Arguments/Submissions

Final argument and reply argument submissions are an opportunity for interveners and the applicant to make their final argument and summarize their position.

Title Document Description
Creative Energy Final Argument Final Argument November 20, 2018
CEC Final Argument Final Argument November 30, 2018
Creative Energy Reply Argument Reply Argument December 10, 2018
CEC Sur Reply Sur Reply December 12, 2018
Creative Energy Final Argument and Comments on CEC’s Extension Request Final Argument August 16, 2019
CEC Final Argument Final Argument September 19, 2019
Creative Energy Reply Argument on specific scope Reply Argument on specific scope September 26, 2019

Exhibits

A Exhibits — BCUC Documents

A Exhibits are issued by the BCUC and can include panel appointment letters, procedural orders, and information requests. A2 exhibits are added to the proceeding by BCUC staff. These can include staff reports, consultant reports, or other relevant evidence filed outside of the proceeding.

Date Title Document Description
July 11, 2018 A-1 Letter dated July 11, 2018 - Appointing the Panel for the review of Creative Energy Vancouver Platforms Inc. Application for Certificate of Public Convenience and Necessity for the Expo and Beatty Plant Project and Approvals Related to Reorganization
July 13, 2018 A-2 Letter date July 13, 2018 – Establishing a Regulatory Timetable and Public Notice
July 17, 2018 A-3 Letter dated July 17, 2018 – Amending the Panel for the review of the application
July 20, 2018 A-4 Letter dated July 20, 2018 – Information regarding August 2, 2018 Workshop
August 17, 2018 A-5 Letter dated August 17, 2018 – Information Request No. 1 to Creative Energy
August 17, 2018 A-5-1 CONFIDENTIAL Letter dated August 17, 2018 – Information Request No. 1 to Creative Energy
August 22, 2018 A-6 Letter dated August 22, 2018 – Parties Submissions on Terms of References for an Independent Appraisal of Surplus Land
August 31, 2018 A-7 Letter dated August 31, 2018 – BCUC response to Creative Energy extension request
September 07, 2018 A-8 Letter dated September 7, 2018 – BCUC Independent Appraiser’s Reply Comments regarding scope of the Terms of Reference
September 19, 2018 A-9 Letter dated September 19, 2018 – BCUC response regarding Submissions on the Terms of Reference and Land Value Assessment
September 26, 2018 A-10 Letter dated September 26, 2018 – BCUC letter regarding confidentiality of material, with Panel Questions regarding the Amalgamation in Appendix A
September 28, 2018 A-11 Letter dated September 28, 2018 – BCUC letter regarding submissions on amalgamation
October 09, 2018 A-12 Letter dated October 9, 2018 – BCUC request Creative Energy provide a response regarding CEC’s Information Request No. 1.7.4
October 10, 2018 A-13 Letter dated October 10, 2018 – BCUC request Creative Energy file as evidence the Appendices 1-4
October 12, 2018 A-14 Letter dated October 12, 2018 – BCUC Order G-194-18 establishing a further regulatory timetable
October 12, 2018 A-15 Letter dated October 12, 2018 – BCUC Submitting Appraisal Report for 720 Beatty Street and 701 Expo Boulevard, Vancouver, BC
October 23, 2018 A-16 Letter dated October 23, 2018 – BCUC Order G-203-18 with reasons for decision
October 23, 2018 A-17 Letter dated October 23, 2018 – BCUC Response to CEC Request
October 25, 2018 A-18 Letter dated October 25, 2018 – BCUC Information Request No. 2 to Creative Energy
October 25, 2018 A-18-1 CONFIDENTIAL Letter dated October 25, 2018 – BCUC Confidential Information Request No. 2 to Creative Energy - Letter only
October 25, 2018 A-19 Letter dated October 25, 2018 – BCUC Information Request No. 1 to Grover Elliot
November 13, 2018 A-20 Letter dated November 13, 2018 – Grover Elliot response to BCUC Information Request No. 1
November 14, 2018 A-21 Letter dated November 14, 2018 – Grover Elliot response to CEC Information Request No. 1
November 14, 2018 A-22 Letter dated November 14, 2018 – Grover Elliot response to Creative Energy Information Request No. 1
November 15, 2018 A-23 Letter dated November 15, 2018 – BCUC Order G-216-18 amending the regulatory timetable
November 15, 2018 A-24 Letter dated November 15, 2018 – Panel Information Request No. 1 to Creative Energy
December 13, 2018 A-25 Letter dated December 13, 2018 – BCUC request Creative Energy comment regarding CEC’s sur-reply request
December 18, 2018 A-26 Letter dated December 18, 2018 – BCUC response regarding CEC’s request for Sur Reply
February 01, 2019 A-27 CONFIDENTIAL Letter dated February 1, 2019 – BCUC requesting confirmation regarding confidentiality of data
February 04, 2019 A-28 Letter dated February 4, 2019 – BCUC response regarding confidentiality of data and statements in Appendix A of Exhibit B-22
May 21, 2019 A-29 Letter dated May 21, 2019 – BCUC Order G-107-19 establishing a further regulatory timetable to review Revisions to the Application
June 12, 2019 A-30 Letter dated June 12, 2019 – BCUC Information Request No. 1 on the Specified Scope to Creative Energy
July 15, 2019 A-31 Letter dated July 15, 2019 – Response to Commercial Energy Consumers’ Request
July 15, 2019 A-32 Letter dated July 15, 2019 – BCUC G-159-19 establishing a further regulatory timetable
July 25, 2019 A-33 Letter dated July 25, 2019 – BCUC Information Request No. 2 on the Specified Scope to Creative Energy
August 22, 2019 A-34 Letter dated August 22, 2019 – BCUC G-196-19 amending the regulatory timetable
October 07, 2019 A-35 Letter dated October 7, 2019 – Panel Information Request No. 1 on the Specified Scope to Creative Energy
October 17, 2019 A-36 Letter dated October 17, 2019 – Response to Farris LLP Requests for Relief
December 18, 2019 A-37 Letter dated December 18, 2019 – BCUC G-332-19 with Reasons for Decision responding to PCL’s application for reconsideration
December 23, 2019 A-38 Letter dated December 23, 2019 – Panel Information Request No. 2 on the Specified Scope to Creative Energy
October 17, 2019 A2-1 Letter dated October 17, 2019 – BCUC staff submission - Farris LLP Requests for Relief dated October 15, 2019
October 29, 2019 A2-2 Letter dated October 29, 2019 – BCUC staff submission - Farris LLP Reconsideration Permission Request dated October 24, 2019
November 08, 2019 A2-3 Letter dated November 8, 2019 – BCUC staff submission - Farris LLP Requests for Relief dated November 7, 2019

B Exhibits — Applicant Documents

B Exhibits are issued by the entity, person, or group that submitted the application to the BCUC (applicant). They can include the application, responses to information requests, and other evidence.

Date Title Document Description
July 11, 2018 B-1 CREATIVE ENERGY VANCOUVER PLATFORMS INC. (CREATIVE ENERGY) – Letter dated June 29, 2018 Application for Certificate of Public Convenience and Necessity for the Expo and Beatty Plant Project and Approvals Related to Reorganization
July 11, 2018 B-1-1 CONFIDENTIAL Letter dated June 29, 2018 – Creative Energy Submitting CONFIDENTIAL Appendix C Financial Model
July 12, 2018 B-1-2 Submission dated August 30, 2018 – Creative Vancouver Submitting Amended and Restated Trust and Development Agreement (Fully Executed) – Agreement dated August 10, 2018
August 03, 2018 B-2 Submission dated August 2, 2018 – Workshop Presentation
August 24, 2018 B-3 Letter dated August 24, 2018 – Creative Energy Comments on Scope of Terms of Reference
August 31, 2018 B-4 Letter dated August 31, 2018 – Creative Energy Submitting Extension Request
September 04, 2018 B-5 Letter dated August 31, 2018 – Creative Energy Submitting Responses to BCUC IR No. 1
September 04, 2018 B-5-1 CONFIDENTIAL Letter dated August 31, 2018 – Creative Energy Submitting Responses to Confidential BCUC IR No. 1
September 04, 2018 B-5-2 Letter dated September 7, 2018 – Creative Energy Submitting Supplementary Reponses to BCUC IR No. 1
September 04, 2018 B-5-3 CONFIDENTIAL Letter dated September 7, 2018 – Creative Energy Submitting Supplementary Confidential Attachment 36.1 to BCUC IR No. 1
September 04, 2018 B-5-4 Submission received September 19, 2018 - Creative Energy Supplemental Response to BCUC IR 19.3 and 19.4, Naviworks file attached
September 04, 2018 B-6 Letter dated August 31, 2018 – Creative Energy Submitting Responses to CEC IR No. 1
September 13, 2018 B-7 Letter dated September 13, 2018 – Creative Energy Submitting letter regarding material relevant to the Independent Land Value Assessment
September 28, 2018 B-8 Letter dated September 28, 2018 – Creative Energy Response to BCUC request for clarification of Confidential Attachment
October 02, 2018 B-9 Submission dated October 1, 2018 – Creative Energy Response to Exhibit A-10, BCUC letter regarding confidentiality of material, with Panel Questions regarding the Amalgamation in Appendix A
October 03, 2018 B-10 Letter dated October 3, 2018 – Creative Energy Submission on Amalgamation
October 09, 2018 B-11 Letter dated October 9, 2018 – Creative Energy reply to CEC regarding clarification of Attachment 4 to letter to Grover Elliot and reasons for confidentiality
October 10, 2018 B-12 Submission dated October 10, 2018 - Creative Energy submitting as evidence Appendices 1-3 previously provided to Grover, Elliot & Co. Ltd.
October 10, 2018 B-12-1 CONFIDENTIAL - Submission dated October 10, 2018 - Creative Energy submitting as evidence Confidential Appendix 4 previously provided to Grover, Elliot & Co. Ltd.
October 11, 2018 B-13 Letter dated October 11, 2018 – Creative Energy response to Exhibit A-12 regarding CEC Information Request
October 15, 2018 B-14 Letter dated October 15, 2018 – Creative Energy reply submission regarding amalgamation
October 25, 2018 B-15 Letter dated October 25, 2018 - Creative Energy submitting Information Request No. 1 to Grover Elliot
October 25, 2018 B-16 Letter dated October 31, 2018 – Creative Energy submitting customer survey
November 08, 2018 B-17 Letter dated November 8, 2018 – Creative Energy submitting responses to CEC Information Request No. 2
November 09, 2018 B-18 Letter dated November 8, 2018 – Creative Energy submitting responses to BCUC Information Request No. 2
November 09, 2018 B-18-1 CONFIDENTIAL - Letter dated November 8, 2018 – Creative Energy submitting CONFIDENTIAL Attachments 85.12 and 134.1 to BCUC Information Request No. 2 responses
November 15, 2018 B-19 Letter dated November 15, 2018 – Creative Energy submitting timetable extension request
November 19, 2018 B-20 Letter dated November 19, 2018 – Creative Energy submitting responses to BCUC Panel Information Request No. 1
December 14, 2018 B-21 Letter dated December 14, 2018 – Creative Energy submitting response to BCUC regarding CEC’s sur-reply request
February 01, 2019 B-22 Letter dated February 1, 2019 – Creative Energy submitting response to BCUC Exhibit A-27 regarding confidentiality of data and statements
May 14, 2019 B-23 Letter dated April 26, 2019 – Creative Energy submitting response to BCUC Decision and Order G-38-19
July 02, 2019 B-24 Letter dated June 28, 2019 – Creative Energy submitting response to BCUC IR No. 1 on the Specified Scope
July 02, 2019 B-25 Letter dated June 28, 2019 – Creative Energy submitting response to CEC IR No. 1 on the Specified Scope
July 08, 2019 B-26 Letter dated July 8, 2019 – Creative Energy submitting comments on further process
July 22, 2019 B-27 Letter dated July 22, 2019 – Creative Energy submitting response to CEC Specified Scope Information Requests 11.9 and 11.10
August 15, 2019 B-28 Letter dated August 15, 2019 – Creative Energy submitting response to BCUC IR No. 2 on the Specified Scope
August 15, 2019 B-29 Letter dated August 15, 2019 – Creative Energy submitting response to CEC IR No. 2 on the Specified Scope
October 11, 2019 B-30 Letter dated October 11, 2019 – Creative Energy submitting response to BCUC Panel IR No. 1 on the Specified Scope
October 11, 2019 B-30-1 Letter dated October 15, 2019 – Creative Energy submitting errata to the responses to BCUC Panel IR No. 1 on the Specified Scope
October 30, 2019 B-31 Letter dated October 30, 2019 – Creative Energy submitting response to Requests for Relief
January 06, 2020 B-32 Letter dated January 6, 2020 – Creative Energy submitting responses to Panel Information Request No. 2 on the Specified Scope
January 14, 2020 B-33 Letter dated January 14, 2020 – Creative Energy submitting no rebuttal response to CEC comment

C Exhibits — Intervener Documents

C Exhibits are issued by registered interveners and can include information requests, submissions on process, and other evidence. To see the list of interveners in this proceeding, please click the "Intervener List" heading below.



Date Title Document Description
July 25, 2018 C1-1 CITY CENTRE CARE SOCIETY (CCCS) – Letter dated July 17, 2018 – Request for Intervener Status by James Lee
July 25, 2018 C2-1 FORTISBC ALTERNATIVE ENERGY SERVICES INC. (FAES) – Letter dated July 17, 2018 – Request for Intervener Status by Grant Bierlmeier
August 01, 2018 C3-1 COMMERCIAL ENERGY CONSUMERS ASSOCIATION OF BRITISH COLUMBIA (CEC) Letter dated July 31, 2018 – Request for Intervener Status by Christopher Weafer
August 17, 2018 C3-2 Letter dated August 17, 2018 – CEC Information Request No. 1 to Creative Energy
August 24, 2018 C3-3 Letter dated August 24, 2018 – CEC Submitting Comments on Scope of Terms of Reference
October 04, 2018 C3-4 Letter dated October 4, 2018 – CEC follow up on Information Request to Creative Energy
October 04, 2018 C3-5 Letter dated October 4, 2018 – CEC Submitting Comments on Attachment 4
October 10, 2018 C3-6 Letter dated October 10, 2018 – CEC Submission regarding Amalgamation
October 10, 2018 C3-7 Submission dated October 10, 2018 – David Craig submitting Confidential Undertaking on behalf of CEC
October 10, 2018 C3-8 Submission dated October 10, 2018 – Christopher Weafer submitting Confidential Undertaking on behalf of CEC
October 15, 2018 C3-9 Letter dated October 15, 2018 – CEC submitting response regarding Exhibit B-13, Creative Energy response regarding CEC request for information
October 25, 2018 C3-10 Letter dated October 25, 2018 – CEC submitting Information Request No. 1 to Grover Elliot
October 25, 2018 C3-11 Letter dated October 25, 2018 – CEC submitting Information Request No. 2 to Creative Energy
December 14, 2018 C3-12 Letter dated December 14, 2018 – CEC response to Creative Energy’s response to BCUC regarding CEC’s sur-reply request
June 13, 2019 C3-13 Letter dated June 12, 2019 – CEC submitting Information Request to Creative Energy on the specific Scope
July 08, 2019 C3-14 Letter dated July 8, 2019 – CEC submitting comments on further process
July 25, 2019 C3-15 Letter dated July 25, 2019 – CEC submitting Information Request No. 2 to Creative Energy on the Specified Scope
August 15, 2019 C3-16 Letter dated August 15, 2019 – CEC submitting extension request
October 31, 2019 C3-17 Letter dated October 31, 2019 – CEC submitting response to Requests for Relief
January 14, 2020 C3-18 Letter dated January 14, 2020 – CEC submitting no comment regarding Creative Energy responses to Panel Information Request No. 2 on the Specified Scope
August 01, 2018 C4-1 FORTISBC ENERGY INC. (FEI) Letter dated July 25, 2018 – Request for Intervener Status by Diane Roy
October 10, 2018 C4-2 Letter dated October 10, 2018 – FEI Submission regarding Amalgamation
August 01, 2018 C5-1 BC Pavilion Corporation (BCPC) Letter dated July 30, 2018 – Request for Intervener Status by Clark Ledingham

D Exhibits — Interested Party Documents

D Exhibits include interested party registration forms. Registered interested parties receive email notifications when public information is posted during a BCUC proceeding.

Date Title Document Description
July 20, 2018 D-1 City of Vancouver (CoV) Letter dated July 20, 2018 – Request for Interested Party Status by Ashley St. Clair
August 01, 2018 D-2 EMANATE ENERGY SOLUTIONS INC. (EES) Letter dated August 1, 2018 – Request for Interested Party Status
August 03, 2018 D-3 CITY CENTRE CARE SOCIETY (CCCS) – Letter dated August 2, 2018 – Request for Interested Party Status by James Lee – Changed Status from Intervener Exhibit C1-1

Transcripts

Transcripts are written scripts from procedural conferences, workshops, oral hearings, and other events. They are included on the proceeding record.

Date Title Document Description
August 03, 2018 Transcript Volume 1 Workshop August 2, 2018

Our Review Process

Learn more about how we review applications, which are submitted to us by the entities we regulate. You'll see the types of reviews we conduct and how you can get involved in the process.

Learn more