BC Utilities Commission

British Columbia Utilities Commission An Inquiry into Gasoline and Diesel Prices in British Columbia ~ Project No. 1599007

Completed: 2019

Hearing and Other Documents

Title Document Description
*_Exhibit List Updated: October 11, 2019 @ 11:55 am
*_2019-07-12-Oral Workshop-FAQ Oral Workshop FAQ
BCUC Gasoline and Diesel Prices Inquiry – Final Report Final Report dated August 30, 2019
BCUC Gasoline and Diesel Prices Inquiry – Executive Summary Executive Summary dated August 30, 2019
BCUC Gasoline and Diesel Prices Inquiry – Supplementary Report Supplementary Report dated November 12, 2019

Arguments/Submissions

Title Document Description
Shell Final Argument Final Argument August 8, 2019
Allan Eliesen Final Argument Final Argument August 8, 2019
7-Eleven Final Argument Final Argument August 8, 2019
Supersave Final Argument Final Argument August 8, 2019
Advanced Biofuels Final Argument-Second Revision Final Argument August 8, 2019 - Second Revision on August 12, 2019
Suncor Final Argument Final Argument August 8, 2019
Parkland Final Argument Final Argument August 8, 2019
Imperial Oil Final Argument Final Argument August 8, 2019
7-Eleven Supplemental Final Argument Supplemental Final Argument October 8, 2019
Imperial Oil Supplemental Final Argument Supplemental Final Argument October 8, 2019
Advanced Biofuels Supplemental Final Argument Supplemental Final Argument October 8, 2019
Parkland Supplemental Final Argument Supplemental Final Argument October 8, 2019
Suncor Supplemental Final Argument Supplemental Final Argument October 8, 2019

Exhibits

A Exhibits - BCUC Documents

Date Title Document Description
May 24, 2019 A-1 Letter dated May 24, 2019 – Appointing the Panel for the review of the British Columbia Utilities Commission Inquiry into Gasoline and Diesel Prices in British Columbia
May 24, 2019 A-2 Letter dated May 24, 2019 – Order G-112-19 establishing a Regulatory Timetable and Survey Questionnaire
May 28, 2019 A-3 Letter dated May 28, 2019 – Clarification regarding the Regulatory Timetable
June 04, 2019 A-4 Letter June 4, 2019 – Consultant Report Terms of Reference
July 08, 2019 A-5 Letter dated July 8, 2019 – BCUC Order G-148-19 advanced approval of confidentiality
July 09, 2019 A-6 Letter dated July 9, 2019 – Oral Workshop Information
July 09, 2019 A-6-1 Letter dated July 12, 2019 – Updated schedule and dated correction to Oral Workshop
July 10, 2019 A-7 Letter dated July 10, 2019 – BCUC response to Parkland’s letter dated July 9, 2019
July 10, 2019 A-8 Letter dated July 10, 2019 – Oral Workshop Questions
July 11, 2019 A-8-1 Letter dated July 12, 2019 - Correction regarding Exhibit A-8
July 11, 2019 A-8-2 Letter dated July 16, 2019 – BCUC Correction to Exhibit A-8
July 11, 2019 A-8-3 Letter dated July 16, 2019 – BCUC Correction to Exhibit A-8
July 11, 2019 A-9 Letter dated July 11, 2019 – BCUC Response to Shell Exhibit C10-3
July 11, 2019 A-10 CONFIDENTIAL – Letter dated July 12, 2019 – BCUC Confidential Oral Workshop Questions to 7-Eleven
July 11, 2019 A-11 CONFIDENTIAL– Letter dated July 12, 2019 - BCUC Confidential Oral Workshop Questions to Super Save
July 23, 2019 A-12 Letter dated July 23, 2019 – Order G-161-19 amending the regulatory timetable
July 23, 2019 A-13 Letter dated July 23, 2019 – Order G-162-19 establishing further confidentiality provisions
July 25, 2019 A-14 Letter dated July 25, 2019 – Order G-165-19 Amending Confidentiality Provisions
July 25, 2019 A-15 Letter dated July 25, 2019 – Further Oral Workshop Panel Questions and Schedule
July 26, 2019 A-16 Letter dated July 26, 2019 – Panel Questions and Oral Workshop Invitation to Federated Co-Operatives Limited (FCL)
July 26, 2019 A-17 Letter dated July 26, 2019 – Panel Questions and Oral Workshop Invitation to Trans Mountain
July 31, 2019 A-18 Letter dated July 31, 2019 – Panel Question to Advanced Biofuels
July 31, 2019 A-19 Letter dated July 31, 2019 – Request for Comment on Confidentiality of Transcripts
August 01, 2019 A-20 Letter dated August 1, 2019 – Cancellation of August 1, 2019 Oral Workshop session
August 01, 2019 A-21 Letter dated August 1, 2019 – Panel Questions to Dr. Kahwaty
August 01, 2019 A-22 Letter dated August 1, 2019 – Instructions on Final Submissions
August 01, 2019 A-23 CONFIDENTIAL – Letter dated August 1, 2019 – Panel Questions to Shell
August 09, 2019 A-24 Letter dated August 9, 2019 – Request for Intervener Submissions on TransMountain Letter of Comment
August 12, 2019 A-25 Letter dated August 12, 2019 – Response to Advanced Biofuels Objection to Imperial Oil’s Final Submission
August 23, 2019 A-26 Letter dated August 23, 2019 – Advanced Biofuels Comments and Suncor Reply Comments to Exhibit A2-30
August 29, 2019 A-27 Letter dated August 29, 2019 – Information regarding the use of Confidential Information in BCUC’s Final Report
September 09, 2019 A-28 Letter dated September 9, 2019 – OIC 470 Amending OIC No. 254/2019 regarding the 30-day comment submission period
September 10, 2019 A-29 Letter dated September 10, 2019 – Order G-216-19 amending the regulatory timetable
September 12, 2019 A-30 Letter dated September 12, 2019 – Footnote corrections to the Final Report
September 20, 2019 A-31 Letter dated September 20, 2019 – Response to Imperial Oil extension request to file additional confidential evidence
September 24, 2019 A-32 Letter dated September 24, 2019 – Response to Suncor and Advanced Biofuels regarding an extension request to file additional intervener evidence
September 30, 2019 A-33 Letter dated September 30, 2019 – BCUC Panel Information Request No. 1 to Parkland
September 30, 2019 A-34 Letter dated September 30, 2019 – BCUC Panel Information Request No. 1 to Suncor
October 02, 2019 A-35 Letter dated October 2, 2019 – Additional Panel Information Request No. 1 to Parkland Fuel Corporation
June 20, 2019 A2-1 Letter dated June 20, 2019 – BCUC staff filing Independent Consultant Report by the Deetken Group - Phase 1: Primer On BC’s Market For Refined Petroleum Products – June 20, 2019
June 20, 2019 A2-1-1 Letter dated July 10, 2019 – BCUC staff filing Independent Consultant Report by the Deetken Group - Phase 2: Analysis of Factors Contributing to BC’s Gasoline and Diesel Price Behaviour
June 20, 2019 A2-1-2 Letter dated July 17,2019 – BCUC staff filing Deetken Group Elise Lepine CV at Oral Workshop
June 20, 2019 A2-1-3 Letter dated July 18, 2019 – BCUC staff filing Deetken Group Update Presentation at Oral Workshop
June 20, 2019 A2-2 Letter dated June 20, 2019 – BCUC staff filing Independent Consultant Report by Navius Research Inc. – Jurisdictional Scan of Regulation and Oversight on Gasoline and Diesel Prices in Canada and North America – June 20, 2019
June 20, 2019 A2-3 Letter dated June 20, 2019 – BCUC staff filing Presentation by Kent Group – Introduction to the Downstream Petroleum Industry – June 17, 2019 and 2018 National Retail Petroleum Site Census – June 7, 2019
June 20, 2019 A2-4 Letter dated June 20, 2019 – BCUC staff filing National Energy Board (NEB) – Western Canada Crude Oil Supply – December 2018
June 20, 2019 A2-5 Letter dated June 20, 2019 – BCUC staff filing NEB – Canadian Refinery Overview – April 2018
June 20, 2019 A2-6 Letter dated June 20, 2019 – BCUC staff filing U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) – West Coast Transportation Fuel Markets – September 2015
June 20, 2019 A2-7 Letter dated June 20, 2019 – BCUC staff filing Scott Hempling, Attorney at Law – Utility Regulation: What Is It, Why We Have It, and How Does It Work? – May 28, 2019
June 20, 2019 A2-8 Letter dated June 20, 2019 – BCUC staff filing Project Overview - Vancouver Airport Fuel Facilities Corporation – Project Overview-Fuel Delivery Project – May 30, 2019
June 20, 2019 A2-9 Letter dated June 20, 2019 – BCUC staff filing Kinder Morgan Canada Limited - Vancouver Wharves Diesel Handling Facility Expansion Project – March 2018
June 20, 2019 A2-10 Letter dated June 20, 2019 – BCUC staff filing NEB – Trans Mountain Pipeline ULC Petroleum Tariff No. 105 Rules and Regulations Governing the Transportation of Petroleum – Issued August 31, 2018
June 20, 2019 A2-11 Letter dated June 20, 2019 – BCUC staff filing NEB – Trans Mountain Pipeline ULC – Petroleum Tariff No. 106: Tolls applying on Petroleum – Issued April 3, 2019
June 20, 2019 A2-12 Letter dated June 20, 2019 – BCUC staff filing Atlantic Institute for Market Studies (AIMS) – What’s Still Missing From Your Wallet? - How Regulation Continues to Distort Gasoline Prices in Atlantic Canada – August 2017
June 20, 2019 A2-13 Letter dated June 20, 2019 – BCUC staff filing NEB – Reason for Decision – Chevron Canada Limited - Application for a priority destination for the Burnaby Refinery, pursuant to section 1.58 of the tariff of Trans Mountain Pipeline ULC – July 2013
June 24, 2019 A2-14 Letter dated June 24, 2019 – BCUC staff filing Competition Bureau of Canada - Factors that affect gas prices at the pumps – July 24, 2018
June 24, 2019 A2-15 Letter dated June 24, 2019 – BCUC staff filing Competition Bureau of Canada – A Guide to Retail Gasoline Pricing in Canada – issued May 17, 2019
June 24, 2019 A2-16 Letter dated June 24, 2019 – BCUC staff filing Competition Bureau of Canada – Government of Canada – Recent investigation into activities in the gasoline and petroleum sectors – February 14, 2018
June 25, 2019 A2-17 Letter dated June 25, 2019 – BCUC staff filing Natural Resources Canada – Why gasoline prices go up and down? – issued August 24, 2016
July 11, 2019 A2-18 Letter dated July 11, 2019 – BCUC staff filing Dr. Mark K. Jaccard – British Columbia Inquiry into Gasoline Pricing Final Report – issued September 30, 1996
July 26, 2019 A2-19 Letter dated July 26, 2019 – BCUC staff filing Petroleum and Renewable Fuels Supply Chain Megan Boutwell, David J. Hackett & Michael L Soares Stillwater Associates LLC February 2014
July 26, 2019 A2-20 Letter dated July 26, 2019 – BCUC staff filing Understanding Crude Oil and Product Markets Steven Levine, Gary Taylor, Daniela Arthur and Michael Tolleth, The Brattle Group
July 26, 2019 A2-21 Letter dated July 26, 2019 – BCUC staff filing The Competition Bureau - Abuse of Dominance Enforcement Guidelines, March 7, 2019
July 26, 2019 A2-22 Letter dated July 26, 2019 – BCUC staff filing The Competition Bureau - Price Maintenance (Section 76 of the Competition Act), September 15, 2014
July 26, 2019 A2-23 Letter dated July 26, 2019 – BCUC staff filing The Competition Bureau - Competitor Collaboration Guidelines, December 23, 2009
July 26, 2019 A2-24 Letter dated July 26, 2019 – BCUC staff filing Director of Investigation and Research v. Imperial Oil Limited, Case decided on: January 26, 1990
July 26, 2019 A2-25 Letter dated July 26, 2019 - BCUC staff filing Gasoline Empirical Analysis: Update of Four Elements of the January 2001 Conference Board study: ”The Final Fifteen Feet of Hose: The Canadian Gasoline Industry in the Year 2000” March 2005
July 26, 2019 A2-26 Letter dated July 26, 2019 - BCUC staff filing The Impact of Sales-Below-Cost Laws on the U.S. Retail Gasoline Market, February 1999
July 26, 2019 A2-27 Letter dated July 26, 2019 - BCUC staff filing The Effects of Recent Volatility in International Petroleum Markets on Canadian Wholesale and Retail Gasoline Prices A report prepared for the Competition Bureau by Frank Roseman March 2005
July 29, 2019 A2-28 Letter dated July 29,2019 – BCUC staff filing Deetken Group Undertaking 1
August 14, 2019 A2-29 Letter dated August 14, 2019 – BCUC staff filing Oil Price Information Service Staff Analysis
August 15, 2019 A2-29-1 Letter dated August 15, 2019 – Correction to Exhibit A2-29
August 16, 2019 A2-30 Letter dated August 16, 2019 – BCUC staff filing Oil Price Information Service Data BCUC Staff Analysis

C Exhibits - Intervener Documents



Date Title Document Description
June 06, 2019 C1-1 ALLAN, ROBYN AND ELIESEN, MARC (ALLAN AND ELIESEN) Letter dated May 26, 2019 – Request to Intervene by Robyn Allan and Marc Eliesen
June 27, 2019 C1-2 Letter dated June 27, 2019 – Allan and Eliesen Submitting Report – The Case for Regulatory Oversight to Address Market Failure
July 15, 2019 C1-3 Letter dated July 15, 2019 – Allan and Eliesen Submitting need for correction to Oral Workshop Question 3B
July 19, 2019 C1-4 Letter dated July 18, 2019 – Allan and Eliesen Submitting Presentation at Oral Workshop
July 22, 2019 C1-4-1 Letter dated July 21, 2019 – Allan and Eliesen Submitting Trans Mountain Capacity Issues discussed at Oral Workshop
July 22, 2019 C1-4-2 Letter dated July 21, 2019 – Allan and Eliesen Submitting Trans Mountain Methodology for Calculation of 2010 Tolls discussed at Oral Workshop
July 22, 2019 C1-5 Letter dated July 22, 2019 – Allan and Eliesen Submitting Port of Vancouver International Exports and Imports
July 23, 2019 C1-6 Letter dated July 23, 2019 – Allan and Eliesen Submitting as requested Complex Monopoly Model
August 09, 2019 C1-7 Letter dated August 8, 2019 – Allan and Eliesen Submission regarding Trans Mountain
June 10, 2019 C2-1 SUNCOR ENERGY (SUNCOR) Letter dated June 10, 2019 – Request to Intervene by James McLean
June 28, 2019 C2-2 Letter dated June 27, 2019 – Suncor Submitting responses to the BCUC Survey Questionnaire and comments on BCUC Consultant Report
June 28, 2019 C2-2-1 Letter dated July 15, 2019 – Suncor Submitting correction to response to BCUC Survey Questionnaire
July 12, 2019 C2-3 Letter dated July 12, 2019 – Suncor Submitting participation in Oral Workshop
July 16, 2019 C2-4 CONFIDENTIAL – Letter dated July 15, 2019 - Suncor Confidential Evidence Submission
July 18, 2019 C2-5 Letter dated July 18, 2019 – Suncor Submitting Presentation at Oral Workshop
July 18, 2019 C2-6 CONFIDENTIAL - Letter dated July 18, 2019 – Suncor Submitting Confidential Presentation at Oral Workshop
July 29, 2019 C2-7 CONFIDENTIAL - Letter dated July 26, 2019 – Suncor Submitting Confidential Response to Undertaking
July 30, 2019 C2-8 Letter dated July 30, 2019 – Suncor Submitting Presentation at Oral Workshop
July 30, 2019 C2-9 CONFIDENTIAL - Letter dated July 30, 2019 – Suncor Submitting Confidential Information at Oral Workshop
August 06, 2019 C2-10 Confidential submission now made Public per C2-11 - Letter dated August 6, 2019 – Suncor Submitting Additional Confidential Information regarding BCUC Order G-165-19
August 09, 2019 C2-11 Letter dated August 8, 2019 – Suncor Submission regarding revised Confidential Request
August 23, 2019 C2-12 Letter dated August 23, 2019 – Suncor comments on Advanced Biofuels Exhibit C6-7
September 17, 2019 C2-13 Letter dated September 17, 2019 – Suncor preliminary comments and intent to file additional evidence
September 23, 2019 C2-14 Letter dated Septemer23, 2019 – Suncor Submitting Request for Extension to file Additional Intervener Evidence
September 25, 2019 C2-15 Letter dated September 24, 2019 – Suncor Submitting Additional Intervener Evidence
October 04, 2019 C2-16 Letter dated October 4, 2019 – Suncor Submitting Response to Panel Information Request No. 1
June 10, 2019 C3-1 SUPER SAVE GROUP (SUPER SAVE GROUP) Letter dated June 10, 2019 – Request to Intervene by Jim Allen
June 28, 2019 C3-2 Letter dated June 27, 2019 – Super Save Group Submitting Intervener Evidence (cover letter)
July 02, 2019 C3-3 CONFIDENTIAL – Letter dated June 27, 2019 – Super Save Group Submitting Confidential document
July 19, 2019 C3-4 CONFIDENTIAL - Letter dated July 19, 2019 - Super Save Group Confidential Submissions at Oral Workshop
July 19, 2019 C3-5 CONFIDENTIAL - Letter dated July 19, 2019 - Super Save Group Confidential Submissions at Oral Workshop
July 19, 2019 C3-6 CONFIDENTIAL - Letter dated July 19, 2019 - Super Save Group Confidential Submissions at Oral Workshop
July 19, 2019 C3-7 Letter dated June 24, 2019 - Super Save Group Submission 1 - Redacted Questionnaire Responses
July 19, 2019 C3-8 Letter dated July 29, 2019 - Super Save Group Submission 2 - Redacted Questionnaire Responses
July 19, 2019 C3-9 Letter dated July 29, 2019 - Super Save Group Submission 3 - Redacted Questionnaire Responses
August 09, 2019 C3-10 CONFIDENTIAL - Letter dated August 8, 2019 - Super Save Group Confidential Submission on Transcript Corrections
September 20, 2019 C3-11 Letter dated September 20, 2019 - Super Save Group Submitting Updated Charts
June 12, 2019 C4-1 NATIONAL ENERGY BOARD (NEB) Letter dated June 11, 2019 – Request to Intervene by Colette Craig
June 27, 2019 C4-2 Letter dated June 27, 2019 – NEB Submitting comments on BCUC Consultant Report by Navius Research Inc.
June 27, 2019 C4-3 Letter dated June 27, 2019 – NEB Submitting Direct Evidence: The Regulation of Pipeline Tolls and Tariffs
July 15, 2019 C4-4 Letter dated July 15, 2019 – NEB Submitting participation in Oral Workshop
July 19, 2019 C4-5 Letter dated July 19, 2019 – NEB Submission at Oral Workshop
July 19, 2019 C4-6 Letter dated July 19, 2019 – NEB Submission at Oral Workshop
August 01, 2019 C4-7 Letter dated August 1, 2019 – NEB Submitting written responses to Oral Workshop Questions
September 18, 2019 C4-8 Letter dated September 18, 2019 – Canada Energy Regulator (CER) submission regarding further participation
June 12, 2019 C5-1 PARKLAND FUEL CORPORATION (PARKLAND) Letter dated June 12, 2019 – Request to Intervene by Christy Elliott
June 28, 2019 C5-2 Letter dated June 27, 2019 – Parkland Submitting Evidence
July 05, 2019 C5-3 Letter dated July 5, 2019 – Parkland Submitting request BCUC response regarding Confidential Information and Procedural Fairness
July 09, 2019 C5-4 Letter dated July 9, 2019 – Parkland Submitting response to BCUC Exhibit A-5 regarding Confidential Information and Procedural Fairness
July 15, 2019 C5-5 Letter dated July 15, 2019 – Parkland Submitting participation at Oral Workshop
July 16, 2019 C5-6 Letter dated July 16, 2019 – Parkland Submitting advance responses to Oral Workshop Questions
July 16, 2019 C5-6-1 CONFIDENTIAL - Letter dated July 16, 2019 Parkland Submitting Confidential responses to Oral Workshop Questions
July 17, 2019 C5-7 Letter dated July 17, 2019 – Parkland Submitting National Post article at Oral Workshop
July 17, 2019 C5-8 Letter dated July 17, 2019 – Parkland Submitting Presentation at Oral Workshop
July 17, 2019 C5-9 Letter dated July 17, 2019 – Parkland Submitting Dr. Kahwaty Slides at Oral Workshop
July 19, 2019 C5-10 Letter dated July 19, 2019 – Parkland Submitting Minister’s statement on January labour force statistics at Oral Workshop
July 19, 2019 C5-11 Letter dated July 19, 2019 – Parkland Submitting Hawaii Research and Economic Analysis Energy Industry Information Reporting Program at Oral Workshop
July 19, 2019 C5-12 Letter dated July 19, 2019 – Parkland Submitting 2010 EIIRP Reporting Schedule “A” at Oral Workshop
July 19, 2019 C5-13 Letter dated July 19, 2019 – Parkland Submitting EIIRP Instruction Forms at Oral Workshop
July 19, 2019 C5-14 Letter dated July 19, 2019 – Parkland Submitting California Energy Commission Report at Oral Workshop
July 19, 2019 C5-15 Letter dated July 19, 2019 – Parkland Submitting Washington State Quarterly Gasoline Report at Oral Workshop
July 19, 2019 C5-16 Letter dated July 19, 2019 – Parkland Submitting University of Washington 2007-2008 Gas Price Study at Oral Workshop
July 29, 2019 C5-17 CONFIDENTIAL – Letter dated July 26, 2019 Parkland Submitting Confidential responses to Undertaking 1
July 29, 2019 C5-18 Letter dated July 26, 2019 Parkland Submitting responses to Undertaking 2
July 29, 2019 C5-19 Letter dated July 26, 2019 Parkland Submitting responses to Undertaking 3
July 29, 2019 C5-20 CONFIDENTIAL – Letter dated July 26, 2019 Parkland Submitting Confidential responses to Undertaking 4
July 29, 2019 C5-21 Letter dated July 26, 2019 Parkland Submitting responses to Undertaking 5
July 29, 2019 C5-22 CONFIDENTIAL – Letter dated July 26, 2019 Parkland Submitting Confidential responses to Undertaking 6
July 29, 2019 C5-23 Letter dated July 26, 2019 Parkland Submitting responses to Undertaking 7
July 29, 2019 C5-24 CONFIDENTIAL – Letter dated July 26, 2019 Parkland Submitting Confidential responses to Undertaking 8
July 29, 2019 C5-25 Letter dated July 26, 2019 Parkland Submitting responses to Undertaking 9
August 08, 2019 C5-26 CONFIDENTIAL – Letter dated August 8, 2019 Parkland Submitting further Confidential responses to Further Panel Questions
August 08, 2019 C5-27 CONFIDENTIAL – Letter dated August 8, 2019 Parkland Submitting Confidential Transcript corrections
August 08, 2019 C5-28 Letter dated August 8, 2019 - Parkland witness Dr. Kahwaty Submitting Responses to Panel Questions
September 17, 2019 C5-29 Letter dated September 17, 2019 – Parkland preliminary comments and intent to file evidence
September 24, 2019 C5-30 Letter dated September 23, 2019 – Parkland Submitting Additional Evidence
October 07, 2019 C5-31 Letter dated October 4, 2019 – Parkland Submitting Response to Panel Information Request No. 1
October 08, 2019 C5-32 Letter dated October 8, 2019 – Parkland Submitting Response to Additional Panel Information Request No. 1
June 13, 2019 C6-1 ADVANCED BIOFUELS CANADA (ADVANCED BIOFUELS) Letter dated June 12, 2019 – Request to Intervene by Ian Thomson
June 28, 2019 C6-2 Letter dated June 27, 2019 – Advanced Biofuels Submitting Intervener Evidence
July 11, 2019 C6-3 Letter dated July 10, 2019 – Advanced Biofuels Submitting advance materials for Oral Workshop
July 19, 2019 C6-4 Letter dated July 18,2019 – Advanced Biofuels Submitting Presentation at Oral Workshop
August 06, 2019 C6-5 Letter dated August 6, 2019 – Advanced Biofuels Submitting further information to Panel Question at July 31, 2019 Oral Workshop
August 07, 2019 C6-6 CONFIDENTIAL – Letter dated August 7, 2019 Advanced Biofuels Submitting Confidential material
August 21, 2019 C6-7 Letter dated August 20, 2019 – Advanced Biofuels Submitting Comments on Oil Price Information Service Data BCUC Staff Analysis – Exhibit A2-30
September 17, 2019 C6-8 Letter dated September 17, 2019 – Advanced Biofuels Submitting Intent to File Additional Comments and Evidence
September 23, 2019 C6-9 Letter dated September 23, 2019 – Advanced Biofuels Submitting Request for Extension to file Additional Intervener Evidence
September 25, 2019 C6-10 Letter dated September 24, 2019 – Advanced Biofuels Submitting Additional Intervener Evidence
June 13, 2019 C7-1 HUSKY ENERGY INC. (HUSKY ENERGY) Letter dated June 13, 2019 – Request to Intervene by Krista Friesen
June 28, 2019 C7-2 Letter dated June 27, 2019 – Husky Energy Submitting responses to BCUC Survey Questionnaire
July 16, 2019 C7-3 CONFIDENTIAL - Letter dated July 15, 2019 - Husky Energy Submitting Confidential Further Questionnaire Responses
July 16, 2019 C7-4 Letter dated July 16, 2019 – Husky Submitting details of participation in Oral Worskshop
July 24, 2019 C7-5 Letter dated July 24, 2019 – Husky Request for clarification of confidential scope in BCUC Order G-148-19
July 26, 2019 C7-6 Letter dated July 26, 2019 – Husky Comment regarding Responses to Oral Workshop Questions
July 26, 2019 C7-7 Letter dated August 1, 2019 – Husky responses to additional Panel Questions
July 26, 2019 C7-7-1 CONFIDENTIAL - Letter dated August 1, 2019 – Husky confidential responses to additional Panel Questions
June 13, 2019 C8-1 IMPERIAL OIL LIMITED (IMPERIAL OIL) Letter dated June 13, 2019 – Request to Intervene by Brian Scammell
June 28, 2019 C8-2 Letter dated June 27, 2019 – Imperial Oil Submitting responses to BCUC Survey Questionnaire
June 28, 2019 C8-3 Letter dated June 27, 2019 – Imperial Oil Submitting comments on BCUC Consultant Report
July 12, 2019 C8-4 Letter dated July 12, 2019 – Imperial Oil Submission regarding Oral Workshop
July 12, 2019 C8-5 CONFIDENTIAL - Letter dated August 1, 2019 – Imperial Oil confidential responses to Questionnaire
August 08, 2019 C8-6 CONFIDENTIAL - Letter dated August 8, 2019 – Imperial Oil response to Further Panel Questions dated July 25, 2019
August 08, 2019 C8-6-1 Letter dated August 8, 2019 – Imperial Oil Public response to Further Panel Questions dated July 25, 2019
August 08, 2019 C8-7 CONFIDENTIAL - Letter dated August 8, 2019 – Imperial Oil response to question 10 of the Questionnaire dated May 24, 2019
September 17, 2019 C8-8 Letter dated September 17, 2019 – Imperial Oil intent to file additional evidence
September 20, 2019 C8-9 Letter dated September 19, 2019 – Imperial Oil extension request
September 27, 2019 C8-10 Letter dated September 26, 2019 – Imperial Oil Submitting Additional Intervener Evidence
June 14, 2019 C9-1 7-ELEVEN CANADA, INC. (7-ELEVEN) Letter dated June 13, 2019 – Request to Intervene by Kristen Cook
June 28, 2019 C9-2 Letter dated June 27, 2019 – 7-Eleven Submitting Response to BCUC Survey Questionnaire – public version
June 28, 2019 C9-2-1 CONFIDENTIAL - Letter dated June 27, 2019 – 7-Eleven Submitting Response to BCUC Survey Questionnaire
July 18, 2019 C9-3 Letter dated July 18, 2019 – 7-Eleven Submitting Vancouver Sun article on Industrial Land presented at Oral Workshop
July 18, 2019 C9-4 Letter dated July 18, 2019 – 7-Eleven Submitting Vancouver Sun article on Commercial Land presented at Oral Workshop
July 18, 2019 C9-5 Letter dated July 18, 2019 – 7-Eleven Submitting CBRE Marketview article presented at Oral Workshop
August 01, 2019 C9-6 CONFIDENTIAL – Letter dated August 1, 2019 - 7 Eleven Confidential Submission-at-July 30, 2019 Oral-Workshop-
August 08, 2019 C9-7 Letter dated August 8, 2019 - 7 Eleven Submitting Response on Confidentiality of Transcripts
June 24, 2019 C10-1 SHELL CANADA LIMITED (SHELL) Letter dated June 24, 2019 – Request to Intervene by Dan Kolenick
June 28, 2019 C10-2 Letter dated June 27, 2019 – Shell Submitting responses to BCUC Survey Questionnaire
July 10, 2019 C10-3 Letter date July 10, 2019 – Shell Submitting response regarding Oral Workshop
July 17, 2019 C10-4 Letter date July 17, 2019 – Shell Submitting biographies for witness panel
July 25, 2019 C10-5 Letter dated July 15, 2019 – Shell Submitting Responses to Confidential Questionnaire
July 25, 2019 C10-6 CONFIDENTIAL – Letter dated July 24, 2019 – Shell Submitting response to Confidential Undertaking
July 31, 2019 C10-7 CONFIDENTIAL – Letter dated July 31, 2019 – Shell Submitting response to further workshop Panel Questions
August 07, 2019 C10-8 CONFIDENTIAL – Letter dated August 7, 2019 – Shell Submitting Confidential material
July 02, 2019 C11-1 COSTCO WHOLESALE LTD. (COSTCO) Letter dated July 2, 2019 – Request to Intervene by Stuart Shamis
July 12, 2019 C11-2 Letter dated July 12, 2019 – Costco Submitting Response to BCUC Survey Questionnaire – public version
July 19, 2019 C11-2-1 CONFIDENTIAL - Letter dated July 19, 2019 - Costco Confidential Submission to BCUC Survey Questionnaire

D Exhibits — Interested Party Documents

Date Title Document Description
June 05, 2019 D-1 BOSSERT, BRAD – Submission dated June 5, 2019 request for Interested Party Status on behalf of Bulloch Technologies
June 11, 2019 D-2 HUGHES, DARREN – Submission dated June 11, 2019 request for Interested Party Status on behalf of Hughes Petroleum
June 13, 2019 D-3 CANADIAN ASSOCIATION OF PETROLEUM PRODUCERS (CAPP) – Submission dated June 13, 2019 request for Interested Party Status by Beth Lau
July 02, 2019 D-4 BUXTON, DONNA - Submission dated July 2, 2019 request for Interested Party Status
July 05, 2019 D-5 DUFF, MICHAEL - Submission dated July 5, 2019 request for Interested Party Status
July 10, 2019 D-5-1 Letter dated July 5, 2019 – Duff, M. Submitting Comments
July 15, 2019 D-6 TANG, MARCO - Submission dated July 15, 2019 request for Interested Party Status
July 18, 2019 D-7 Hundal, Paul - Submission dated July 18, 2019 request for Interested Party Status
July 18, 2019 D-7-1 Letter dated August 8, 2019 – Hundal, P. submitting Comments
July 31, 2019 D-8 CROSS, GEOFF – Submission dated July 31, 2019 request for Interested Party Status on behalf of Translink
July 31, 2019 D-8-1 Letter dated August 8, 2019 – Cross, G. submitting Comments on behalf of Translink
August 06, 2019 D-9 SEARL, DAVID - Submission dated August 6, 2019 request for Interested Party Status
August 07, 2019 D-10 HUNT, WENDY - Submission dated August 7, 2019 request for Interested Party Status on behalf of District of New Hazelton

E Exhibits - Letters of Comment

Date Title Document Description
May 28, 2019 E-1 Bynoe, D. – Letter of Comment dated May 24, 2019
May 28, 2019 E-2 Diebel, R. – Letter of Comment dated May 24, 2019
May 28, 2019 E-3 Dockter, M. – Letter of Comment dated May 24, 2019
May 28, 2019 E-4 Doyle, A. – Letter of Comment dated May 24, 2019
May 28, 2019 E-5 Euerby, A. – Letter of Comment dated May 24, 2019
May 28, 2019 E-6 Perez, J. – Letter of Comment dated May 24, 2019
May 28, 2019 E-7 Semenec, M. – Letter of Comment dated May 24, 2019
May 28, 2019 E-8 Paller, A. – Letter of Comment dated May 24, 2019
May 28, 2019 E-9 Bouvette, B. – Letter of Comment dated May 25, 2019
May 28, 2019 E-10 Dutour, S. – Letter of Comment dated May 25, 2019
May 28, 2019 E-11 Edwards, J. – Letter of Comment dated May 25, 2019
May 28, 2019 E-12 Fisher, C. – Letter of Comment dated May 25, 2019
May 28, 2019 E-13 Francis, A. – Letter of Comment dated May 25, 2019
May 28, 2019 E-14 Gray, J. – Letter of Comment dated May 25, 2019
May 28, 2019 E-15 Gray, D. – Letter of Comment dated May 25, 2019
May 28, 2019 E-16 Hrelia, M. – Letter of Comment dated May 25, 2019
May 28, 2019 E-17 Lapusniak, T. – Letter of Comment dated May 25, 2019
May 28, 2019 E-18 Postle, P. – Letter of Comment dated May 25, 2019
May 28, 2019 E-18-1 Postle, P. – Letter of Comment dated July 4, 2019
May 28, 2019 E-19 MacAulay, M. – Letter of Comment dated May 25, 2019
May 28, 2019 E-20 Smith, L. – Letter of Comment dated May 25, 2019
May 28, 2019 E-21 Stein, G. – Letter of Comment dated May 25, 2019
May 28, 2019 E-22 Tate, J. – Letter of Comment dated May 25, 2019
May 28, 2019 E-23 LaPointe, R. – Letter of Comment dated May 26, 2019
May 28, 2019 E-24 Marshall, R. – Letter of Comment dated May 26, 2019
May 28, 2019 E-25 Strube, C. – Letter of Comment dated May 26, 2019
May 29, 2019 E-26 Albert, L. – Letter of Comment dated May 28, 2019
May 31, 2019 E-27 Hunter, F. – Letter of Comment dated May 30, 2019
June 03, 2019 E-28 Antonson, B. – Letter of Comment dated June 1, 2019
June 07, 2019 E-29 Sunshine Coast Labour Council – Letter of Comment dated June 5, 2019
June 07, 2019 E-30 Klee, M. – Letter of Comment dated June 7, 2019
June 11, 2019 E-31 Galasso, D. – Letter of Comment dated June 10, 2019
July 02, 2019 E-32 Mann, K. – Letter of Comment dated July 2, 2019
July 02, 2019 E-33 Nikkel, R. – Letter of Comment dated July 2, 2019
July 02, 2019 E-34 Ulmer, J. – Letter of Comment dated July 1, 2019
July 02, 2019 E-35 Windsor, D. – Letter of Comment dated July 1, 2019
July 03, 2019 E-36 Wilkinson, M. – Letter of Comment dated July 3, 2019
July 04, 2019 E-37 Whalen, B. – Letter of Comment dated July 3, 2019
July 04, 2019 E-38 Grindler, J. – Letter of Comment dated July 3, 2019
July 04, 2019 E-39 Saunders, R. – Letter of Comment dated July 4, 2019
July 05, 2019 E-40 Clay, I. – Letter of Comment dated July 4, 2019
July 05, 2019 E-41 Evans, E. – Letter of Comment dated July 4, 2019
July 08, 2019 E-42 CIPMA-Canadian Fuels Association – Letter of Comment dated July 8, 2019 – Includes 3rd Party Report: Overview BC Fuels Market
July 08, 2019 E-43 Lane, S. – Letter of Comment dated July 5, 2019
July 08, 2019 E-44 Brown, B. – Letter of Comment dated July 8, 2019
July 09, 2019 E-45 Robertson, K. – Letter of Comment dated July 8, 2019
July 09, 2019 E-46 Poy, L. – Letter of Comment dated July 8, 2019
July 12, 2019 E-47 Wilkinson, A. – Letter of Comment dated May 10, 2019 on behalf of the BC Liberal Official Opposition
July 15, 2019 E-48 Hogan, M. - Letter of Comment dated July 14, 2019
July 15, 2019 E-49 Suzuki, T. - Letter of Comment dated July 15, 2019
July 16, 2019 E-50 Wilks, L. – Letter of Comment dated July 15, 2019
July 16, 2019 E-51 Toshio – Letter of Comment dated July 16, 2019
July 17, 2019 E-52 Janyk, B. - Letter of Comment dated July 17, 2019
July 18, 2019 E-53 Savitski, C. - Letter of Comment dated July 18, 2019
July 18, 2019 E-54 Appleton, R. - Letter of Comment dated July 18, 2019
July 18, 2019 E-55 Ramus, S. - Letter of Comment dated July 18, 2019
July 18, 2019 E-56 Osborne, N. - Letter of Comment dated July 18, 2019
July 18, 2019 E-57 O’Hearn, J. - Letter of Comment dated July 18, 2019
July 19, 2019 E-58 Gandevia, D. – Letter of Comment dated July 18, 2019
July 19, 2019 E-59 Moran, A. – Letter of Comment dated July 19, 2019
July 19, 2019 E-60 Barber, R. – Letter of Comment dated July 10, 2019
July 22, 2019 E-61 Toth, S. – Letter of Comment dated July 20, 2019
August 01, 2019 E-62 Wilson, A.F. – Letter of Comment dated July 17, 2019
August 06, 2019 E-63 Jansson, M. – Letter of Comment dated August 6, 2019
August 06, 2019 E-64 Value Chain Solutions – Letter of Comment dated July 26, 2019
August 07, 2019 E-65 Wind, B. - Letter of Comment dated August 5, 2019
August 08, 2019 E-66 Federated Co-operatives Limited (FCL) - Letter of Comment dated August 7, 2019
August 08, 2019 E-67 Wong, A. - Letter of Comment dated August 7, 2019
August 08, 2019 E-68 Trans Mountain Pipeline - Letter of Comment dated August 7, 2019
August 08, 2019 E-69 Brayshaw, W. – Letter of Comment dated August 8, 2019
August 08, 2019 E-70 Cooper, P. – Letter of Comment dated August 8, 2019
September 11, 2019 E-71 Palmer, C. - Letter of Commend dated September 4, 2019
September 13, 2019 E-72 Blom, J. - Letter of Comment dated September 11, 2019
September 13, 2019 E-73 Brooks-Thoma, M. - Letter of Comment dated September 11, 2019
September 13, 2019 E-74 Burns, P. - Letter of Comment dated September 11, 2019
September 13, 2019 E-75 Burton, S. - Letter of Comment dated September 11, 2019
September 13, 2019 E-76 Coombers - Letter of Comment dated September 11, 2019
September 13, 2019 E-77 Eacott, L. - Letter of Comment dated September 11, 2019
September 13, 2019 E-78 Gerow-Larry - Letter of Comment dated September 11, 2019
September 13, 2019 E-78-1 Gerow-Larry – Additional Letter of Comment dated September 11, 2019
September 13, 2019 E-79 Guindon, J - Letter of Comment dated September 11, 2019
September 13, 2019 E-80 Kalawarny, C. - Letter of Comment dated September 11, 2019
September 13, 2019 E-81 Morehouse, A. - Letter of Comment dated September 11, 2019
September 13, 2019 E-82 Rubboli, S. - Letter of Comment dated September 11, 2019
September 13, 2019 E-83 Taronna, S. - Letter of Comment dated September 11, 2019
September 13, 2019 E-84 Speckling, B. - Letter of Comment dated September 11, 2019
September 13, 2019 E-85 Woods, G. - Letter of Comment dated September 11, 2019
September 13, 2019 E-86 Kersey, J. and D. - Letter of Comment dated September 11, 2019
September 13, 2019 E-87 Woods, R. and D. - Letter of Comment dated September 11, 2019
September 13, 2019 E-88 Brown-Win - Letter of Comment dated September 11, 2019
September 16, 2019 E-89 Segade, K. – Letter of Comment dated September 16, 2019
September 23, 2019 E-90 Woods, T. and L.– Letter of Comment dated September 22, 2019
September 23, 2019 E-91 Perrin, K. – Letter of Comment dated September 22, 2019
September 24, 2019 E-92 Bedford, S. – Letter of Comment dated September 23, 2019
September 24, 2019 E-93 Bouvier, D. – Letter of Comment dated September 23, 2019
October 02, 2019 E-94 Suzuki, T. – Letter of Comment dated September 30, 2019
October 04, 2019 E-94-1 Suzuki, T. – Letter of Comment dated October 4, 2019
October 04, 2019 E-95 O’Brien, W. – Letter of Comment dated October 4, 2019
October 10, 2019 E-96 Simons, N. and Hill, R. - Letter of Comment dated October 10, 2019
October 10, 2019 E-97 Logan, R. - Letter of Comment dated October 10, 2019
October 10, 2019 E-98 MacLeod, M. – Letter of Comment dated October 10, 2019
October 11, 2019 E-99 Armitage, A. – Letter of Comment dated October 10, 2019
October 11, 2019 E-100 Cardinall, S. – Letter of Comment dated October 10, 2019
October 11, 2019 E-101 Chalmers, R. – Letter of Comment dated October 10, 2019
October 11, 2019 E-102 Crivea, E. – Letter of Comment dated October 10, 2019
October 11, 2019 E-103 Currie, S. – Letter of Comment dated October 10, 2019
October 11, 2019 E-104 Davey, W.J. – Letter of Comment dated October 10, 2019
October 11, 2019 E-105 MacKenzie, J. – Letter of Comment dated October 10, 2019
October 11, 2019 E-106 Marshall, D. – Letter of Comment dated October 10, 2019
October 11, 2019 E-107 Martin, P. – Letter of Comment dated October 10, 2019
October 11, 2019 E-108 McLaurin, K. – Letter of Comment dated October 10, 2019
October 11, 2019 E-109 Shuley, P. – Letter of Comment dated October 10, 2019
October 11, 2019 E-110 Wretham, A. – Letter of Comment dated October 10, 2019
October 11, 2019 E-111 Young, K. – Letter of Comment dated October 10, 2019

Transcripts

Date Title Document Description
July 17, 2019 Transcript Volume (Master Appearance Index) Master Appearance Index Oral Workshop July 17-19, 2019
July 17, 2019 Transcript Volume 1 (Partial) Oral Workshop July 17, 2019
July 17, 2019 Transcript Volume 1 (Full) Oral Workshop July 17, 2019
July 17, 2019 Transcript Volume 1A-Redacted Confidential Proceedings - Oral Workshop July 17, 2019
July 22, 2019 Transcript Volume 2 Oral Workshop July 18, 2019
July 23, 2019 Transcript Volume 3 Oral Workshop July 19, 2019
July 30, 2019 Transcript Volume 4 Oral Workshop July 30, 2019
August 08, 2019 Transcript Volume 4A-Parkland Redacted Oral Workshop July 30, 2019
August 15, 2019 Transcript Volume 2A and 4B - Redacted Confidential Proceedings – Oral Workshop July 18, 2019 and July 30, 2019

Our Review Process

Learn more about how we review applications, which are submitted to us by the entities we regulate. You'll see the types of reviews we conduct and how you can get involved in the process.

Learn more