BC Utilities Commission

Review of British Columbia Hydro and Power Authority’s Performance Based Regulation Report

Completed: 2022

Hearing and Other Documents

Title Document Description
EXHIBIT LIST Updated: March 23, 2021 @ 4:58 pm
Decision and Order G-388-21 Decision and Order G-388-21 December 21, 2021

Arguments/Submissions

Title Document Description
BC Hydro Final Argument Final Argument May 3, 2021
BCOAPO Final Argument Final Argument June 1, 2021
CEC Final Argument Final Argument June 1, 2021
Gjoshe Final Argument Final Argument June 1, 2021
BCSEA Final Argument Final Argument June 1, 2021
ZoneII-Ratepayers Final Argument Final Argument June 1, 2021
RCIA Final Argument Final Argument June 1, 2021
MoveUP Final Argument Final Argument June 1, 2021
CEABC Final Argument Final Argument June 1, 2021
AMPC Final Argument Final Argument June 1, 2021
BCH Reply Argument Reply Argument June 24, 2021

Exhibits

A Exhibits - BCUC Documents

Date Title Document Description
October 11, 2019 A-1 Letter dated October 11, 2019 – BCUC Order G-245-19 establishing a proceeding and appointing the Panel for the British Columbia Hydro and Power Authority Review of the Performance Based Regulation Report
October 11, 2019 A-2 Letter dated October 11, 2019 – BCUC Order G-246-19 establishing a Regulatory Timetable
November 14, 2019 A-3 Letter dated November 14, 2019 – Procedural conference information
December 12, 2019 A-4 Letter dated December 12, 2019 – BCUC Order G-326-19 furthering the Regulatory Timetable with Reasons for Decision
March 09, 2020 A-5 Letter dated March 9, 2020 – BCUC clarification on high level topics to BCUC Staff Consultant Report
March 17, 2020 A-6 Letter dated March 17, 2020 – BCUC requesting submissions on rescheduled workshop dates
March 27, 2020 A-7 Letter dated March 27, 2020 – BCUC Order G-70-20 amending the regulatory timetable
September 01, 2020 A-8 Letter dated September 1, 2020 – BCUC facilitated workshop information
September 17, 2020 A-9 Letter dated September 17, 2020 – BCUC Request for Submissions on Further Process
October 06, 2020 A-10 Letter dated October 6, 2020 – BCUC Order G-251-20 amending the regulatory timetable
December 09, 2020 A-11 Letter dated December 9, 2020 – BCUC Order G-324-20 amending the regulatory timetable
December 21, 2020 A-12 Letter dated December 21, 2020 – BCUC Information Request No. 1 to BC Hydro on Supplementary Evidence
March 01, 2021 A-13 Letter dated March 1, 2021 – BCUC Request for Oral Submissions on possible scenarios
March 22, 2021 A-14 Letter dated March 23, 2021 – BCUC Order G-92-21 amending the regulatory timetable
October 25, 2019 A2-1 Letter dated October 25, 2019 – British Columbia Hydro and Power Authority Fiscal 2020 to Fiscal 2021 Revenue Requirements Application - Chapter 11, Appendix FF and Appendix GG dated February 25, 2019
October 25, 2019 A2-2 Letter dated October 25, 2019 – British Columbia Hydro and Power Authority Fiscal 2020 to Fiscal 2021 Revenue Requirements Application - Responses to BCUC IR 189.1 to 200.2 dated June 6, 2019
October 25, 2019 A2-3 Letter dated October 25, 2019 – British Columbia Hydro and Power Authority Fiscal 2020 to Fiscal 2021 Revenue Requirements Application - Responses to BCOAPO IR 86.1, 87.1, 88.1; BCSEA IR 58.1, 58.2; MoveUP IR 2.1 to 4.3.1 dated June 6, 2019
October 25, 2019 A2-4 Letter dated October 25, 2019 – British Columbia Hydro and Power Authority Fiscal 2020 to Fiscal 2021 Revenue Requirements Application - Responses to BCUC IR 231.3, 281.1 to 287.1 dated September 3, 2019
February 28, 2020 A2-5 Letter dated February 28, 2020 – BCUC staff filing Consultant Report by Pacific Economics Group Research LLC - Performance-Based Regulation: Basic Features and Possible Applications to BC Hydro
September 09, 2020 A2-6 Letter dated September 9, 2020 – BCUC staff filing presentation document BCUC Performance Based Regulation: An Introduction Dated September 9, 2020
September 09, 2020 A2-7 Letter dated September 9, 2020 – BCUC staff filing consultant presentation document Pacific Economics Group Research LLC Review of BC Hydro’s PBR Report Dated September 9, 2020
November 16, 2020 A2-8 Letter dated November 16, 2020 – BCUC staff filing consultant response to BCSEA IR No. 1
November 16, 2020 A2-9 Letter dated November 16, 2020 – BCUC staff filing consultant response to BCOAPO IR No. 1
November 16, 2020 A2-10 Letter dated November 16, 2020 – BCUC staff filing consultant response to CEABC IR No. 1
November 16, 2020 A2-11 Letter dated November 16, 2020 – BCUC staff filing consultant response to CEC IR No. 1
November 16, 2020 A2-12 Letter dated November 16, 2020 – BCUC staff filing consultant response to Gjoshe IR No. 1
November 16, 2020 A2-13 Letter dated November 16, 2020 – BCUC staff filing consultant response to Zone II RPG IR No. 1

B Exhibits - Applicant Documents

Date Title Document Description
October 18, 2019 B-1 BRITISH COLUMBIA HYDRO AND POWER AUTHORITY (BC HYDRO) – Letter dated October 18, 2019 –Providing a comprehensive list of F20-F21 RRA evidence that should be placed on the Evidentiary Record
November 18, 2019 B-2 Letter dated November 18, 2019 – BC Hydro submission prior to Procedural Conference
November 22, 2019 B-3 Letter dated November 22, 2019 – BC Hydro submitting COSR Timeline Document at Procedural Conference
March 16, 2020 B-4 Letter dated March 16, 2020 – BC Hydro submission regarding regulatory timetable
March 19, 2020 B-5 Letter dated March 19, 2020 – BC Hydro submitting response regarding Workshop Dates
June 30, 2020 B-6 Letter dated June 30, 2020 – BC Hydro submitting clarifying questions and high-level topics
September 30, 2020 B-7 Letter dated September 30, 2020 – BC Hydro submitting response regarding further process
November 30, 2020 B-8 Letter dated November 30, 2020 – BC Hydro submitting Supplementary Evidence
February 04, 2021 B-9 Letter dated February 4, 2021 – BC Hydro submitting responses to BCUC Information Request No. 1
February 04, 2021 B-10 Letter dated February 4, 2021 – BC Hydro submitting responses to Intervener Information Requests No. 1
February 16, 2021 B-11 Letter dated February 16, 2020 – BC Hydro submitting response regarding further process

C Exhibits - Intervener Documents

BC SUSTAINABLE ENERGY ASSOCIATION (BCSEA) - Letter dated October 22, 2019 - submitting evidence list
CATALYST PAPER CORPORATION (CATALYST) – Intervener
FORTISBC ENERGY INC. AND FORTISBC INC. (FORTISBC) – Intervener
RICHARD MCCANDLESS (MCCANDLESS) – Intervener
KWADACHA NATION AND TSAY KEH DENE NATION, TOGETHER THE ZONE II RATEPAYERS GROUP (ZONE II RPG) – Intervener
BRITISH COLUMBIA OLD AGE PENSIONER’S ORGANIZATION ET AL. (BCOAPO) – Intervener
PAUL WILLIS (WILLIS) – Intervener
MOVEMENT OF UNITED PROFESSIONALS (MOVEUP) – Intervener
COMMERCIAL ENERGY CONSUMERS ASSOCIATION OF BRITISH COLUMBIA (CEC) – Intervener
CLEAN ENERGY ASSOCIATION OF BC (CEABC) – Intervener
ASSOCIATION OF MAJOR POWER CUSTOMERS OF BRITISH COLUMBIA (AMPC) – Intervener
DAVID INCE (INCE) – Intervener
STEVE DAVIS & ASSOCIATES CONSULTING LTD. (DAVIS-ASSOCIATES) – Intervener
EDLIRA GJOSHE (GJOSHE) – Intervener
BC NON-PROFIT HOUSING ASSOCIATION (BCNPHA) – Intervener
RESIDENTIAL CONSUMER INTERVENOR GROUP (RCIG) - Letter dated January 22, 2021 Request to Intervene by Lindsay Thompson, Midgard Consulting


Date Title Document Description
October 22, 2019 C1-1 BC SUSTAINABLE ENERGY ASSOCIATION (BCSEA) - Letter dated October 22, 2019 - submitting evidence list
November 22, 2019 C1-2 BCSEA – Intervener
March 17, 2020 C1-3 Letter dated March 17, 2020 – BCSEA submitting clarification questions regarding BCUC Staff Consultant Report
March 18, 2020 C1-4 Letter dated March 18, 2020 – BCSEA submitting response regarding Workshop
June 30, 2020 C1-5 Letter dated June 30, 2020 – BCSEA submitting written clarifying questions or high-level topics to BCUC Staff Consultant
September 30, 2020 C1-6 Letter dated September 30, 2020 – BCSEA submitting response regarding further process
October 28, 2020 C1-7 Letter dated October 28, 2020 – BCSEA submitting Information Request No. 1 to BCUC Staff Consultant
January 07, 2021 C1-8 Letter dated January 7, 2021 – BCSEA submitting Information Request No. 1 to BC Hydro on Supplementary Evidence
February 16, 2021 C1-9 Letter dated February 16, 2020 – BCSEA submitting response regarding further process
November 22, 2019 C2-1 CATALYST PAPER CORPORATION (CATALYST) – Intervener
November 22, 2019 C3-1 FORTISBC ENERGY INC. AND FORTISBC INC. (FORTISBC) – Intervener
November 22, 2019 C4-1 RICHARD MCCANDLESS (MCCANDLESS) – Intervener
November 22, 2019 C5-1 KWADACHA NATION AND TSAY KEH DENE NATION, TOGETHER THE ZONE II RATEPAYERS GROUP (ZONE II RPG) – Intervener
March 17, 2020 C5-2 Letter dated March 17, 2020 – Zone II RPG submitting clarification questions regarding BCUC Staff Consultant Report
March 23, 2020 C5-3 Letter dated March 23, 2020 – Zone IIRPG submitting response regarding Workshop
September 30, 2020 C5-4 Letter dated September 30, 2020 – Zone II RPG submitting response regarding further process
October 28, 2020 C5-5 Letter dated October 28, 2020 – Zone II RPG submitting Information Request No. 1 to BCUC Staff Consultant
January 07, 2021 C5-6 Letter dated January 7, 2021 – Zone II RPG submitting Information Request No. 1 to BC Hydro on Supplementary Evidence
February 16, 2021 C5-7 Letter dated February 16, 2020 – ZoneII RPG submitting response regarding further process
March 19, 2021 C5-8 Letter dated March 19, 2021 – ZoneII RPG submitting response to BCUC Exhibit A-13
November 22, 2019 C6-1 BRITISH COLUMBIA OLD AGE PENSIONER’S ORGANIZATION ET AL. (BCOAPO) – Intervener
March 24, 2020 C6-2 Letter dated March 24, 2020 – BCOAPO submitting response regarding Workshop
June 30, 2020 C6-3 Letter dated June 30, 2020 – BCOAPO submitting written clarifying questions or high-level topics to BCUC Staff Consultant
September 30, 2020 C6-4 Letter dated September 30, 2020 – BCOAPO submitting responses to BCUC on further process
October 28, 2020 C6-5 Letter dated October 28, 2020 – BCOAPO submitting Information Request No. 1 to BCUC Staff Consultant
January 07, 2021 C6-6 Letter dated January 7, 2021 – BCOPAO submitting Information Request No. 1 to BC Hydro on Supplementary Evidence
February 16, 2021 C6-7 Letter dated February 16, 2020 – BCOAPO submitting response regarding further process
November 22, 2019 C7-1 PAUL WILLIS (WILLIS) – Intervener
September 30, 2020 C7-2 Letter dated September 30, 2020 – Willis submitting response regarding further process
November 22, 2019 C8-1 MOVEMENT OF UNITED PROFESSIONALS (MOVEUP) – Intervener
March 12, 2020 C8-2 Letter dated March 12, 2020 – MoveUP submitting clarification questions regarding BCUC Staff Consultant Report
March 17, 2020 C8-3 Letter dated March 17, 2020 – MoveUP submitting response regarding Workshop
June 29, 2020 C8-4 Letter dated June 29, 2020 – MoveUP submitting supplemental questions
September 30, 2020 C8-5 Letter dated September 30, 2020 – MoveUP submitting response regarding further process
January 04, 2021 C8-6 Letter dated January 4, 2021 – MoveUP Information Request No. 1 to BC Hydro on Supplementary Evidence
February 13, 2021 C8-7 Letter dated February 13, 2020 – MoveUP submitting response regarding further process
November 22, 2019 C9-1 COMMERCIAL ENERGY CONSUMERS ASSOCIATION OF BRITISH COLUMBIA (CEC) – Intervener
March 17, 2020 C9-2 Letter dated March 17, 2020 – CEC submitting clarification questions regarding BCUC Staff Consultant Report
March 24, 2020 C9-3 Letter dated March 24, 2020 – CEC submitting response regarding Workshop
June 30, 2020 C9-4 Letter dated June 30, 2020 – CEC submitting written clarifying questions or high-level topics to BCUC Staff Consultant
September 30, 2020 C9-5 Letter dated September 30, 2020 – CEC submitting responses to BCUC on further process
October 29, 2020 C9-6 Letter dated October 28, 2020 – CEC submitting Information Request No. 1 to BCUC Staff Consultant
January 07, 2021 C9-7 Letter dated January 7, 2021 – CEC submitting Information Request No. 1 to BC Hydro on Supplementary Evidence
February 16, 2021 C9-8 Letter dated February 16, 2020 – CEC submitting response regarding further process
November 22, 2019 C10-1 CLEAN ENERGY ASSOCIATION OF BC (CEABC) – Intervener
March 24, 2020 C10-2 Letter dated March 24, 2020 – CEABC submitting response regarding Workshop
September 30, 2020 C10-3 Letter dated September 30, 2020 – CEABC submitting response regarding further process
October 28, 2020 C10-4 Letter dated October 28, 2020 – CEABC submitting Information Request No. 1 to BCUC Staff Consultant
January 07, 2021 C10-5 Letter dated January 7, 2021 – CEABC submitting Information Request No. 1 to BC Hydro on Supplementary Evidence
February 16, 2021 C10-6 Letter dated February 16, 2020 – CEABC submitting response regarding further process
March 19, 2021 C10-7 Letter dated March 19, 2021 – CEABC submitting response to BCUC Exhibit A-13
November 22, 2019 C11-1 ASSOCIATION OF MAJOR POWER CUSTOMERS OF BRITISH COLUMBIA (AMPC) – Intervener
September 30, 2020 C11-2 Letter dated September 30, 2020 – AMPC submitting responses to BCUC on further process
January 07, 2021 C11-3 Letter dated January 7, 2021 – AMPC submitting Information Request No. 1 to BC Hydro on Supplementary Evidence
February 16, 2021 C11-4 Letter dated February 16, 2020 – AMPC submitting response regarding further process
March 19, 2021 C11-5 Letter dated March 19, 2021 – AMPC submitting response to BCUC Exhibit A-13
November 22, 2019 C12-1 DAVID INCE (INCE) – Intervener
November 22, 2019 C13-1 STEVE DAVIS & ASSOCIATES CONSULTING LTD. (DAVIS-ASSOCIATES) – Intervener
November 22, 2019 C14-1 EDLIRA GJOSHE (GJOSHE) – Intervener
March 25, 2020 C14-2 Letter dated March 25, 2020 – Gjoshe submitting late response regarding Workshop
June 30, 2020 C14-3 Letter dated June 30, 2020 – Gjoshe submitting written clarifying questions or high-level topics to BCUC Staff Consultant
September 30, 2020 C14-4 Letter dated September 30, 2020 – Gjoshe submitting response regarding further process
October 29, 2020 C14-5 Letter dated October 28, 2020 – Gjoshe submitting Information Request No. 1 to BCUC Staff Consultant
November 22, 2019 C15-1 BC NON-PROFIT HOUSING ASSOCIATION (BCNPHA) – Intervener
January 22, 2021 C16-1 RESIDENTIAL CONSUMER INTERVENOR GROUP (RCIG) - Letter dated January 22, 2021 Request to Intervene by Lindsay Thompson, Midgard Consulting
February 16, 2021 C16-2 Letter dated February 16, 2020 – RCIG submitting response regarding further process

D Exhibits — Interested Party Documents

Date Title Document Description
October 21, 2019 D-1 INNERGEX RENEWABLE ENERGY (INNERGEX) - Submission dated October 21, 2019 Request for Interested Party Status by Nicola Vaughan
November 28, 2019 D-2 MINISTRY OF ENERGY AND MINES (MEM) - Submission dated November 28, 2019 Request for Interested Party Status by Jack Buchanan

Transcripts

Date Title Document Description
November 22, 2019 Transcript Volume 1 Procedural Conference Vancouver November 22, 2019
September 08, 2020 Transcript Volume 2 Workshop Transcript September 8, 2020
March 22, 2021 Transcript Volume 3 Oral Submissions March 22, 2021

Our Review Process

Learn more about how we review applications, which are submitted to us by the entities we regulate. You'll see the types of reviews we conduct and how you can get involved in the process.

Learn more